The US energy landscape is in constant motion. After the unprecedented price shocks of 2022, the past 2 years brought a degree of stabilization, particularly in wholesale electricity markets, thanks largely to moderated natural gas prices and milder weather. Average wholesale power prices in major US hubs fell significantly from their peaks. However, calling this a return to 'normal' would be premature. Volatility remains the defining characteristic, a persistent undercurrent driven by increasingly extreme weather, the rapid integration of intermittent renewables, and a complex web of evolving regulations.

For energy retailers operating in America's deregulated markets, like Texas and competitive states within the PJM interconnection (such as Pennsylvania, Illinois, Ohio, Maryland, and New Jersey), this environment presents profound challenges and opportunities. Navigating this turbulence requires more than just reacting; it demands foresight, agility, and sophisticated strategies grounded in data. This isn't just about managing risk; it's about understanding the new price of uncertainty and finding ways to thrive within it.

Market turbulence: riding the roller coaster

While average US wholesale prices were lower in 2023-2024 compared to the crisis year of 2022, the ride was far from smooth, especially in markets sensitive to weather and renewable output.

• Weather's widening swings: Climate change is amplifying weather extremes, directly impacting energy demand and supply. Texas, for example, experienced record-breaking heat waves in the summer of 2023, pushing electricity demand to unprecedented highs (peaking at around 85.7 GW in August) and severely testing grid resilience. While ERCOT managed to avoid major outages, it required multiple calls for conservation to maintain operating reserves. These heatwaves, along with intense winter storms like 2021's Uri or late 2022's Elliott, create sudden demand surges and can disrupt generation, leading to dramatic price spikes. Even milder-than-expected weather brings its own form of uncertainty, potentially suppressing demand and prices below forecasts. Retailers must price and hedge for this widening range of possibilities.
• Fuel market echoes: Natural gas remains a primary driver of electricity prices in many US markets. While gas prices have retreated significantly from their 2022 highs, contributing to lower wholesale power costs, the potential for geopolitical events or supply disruptions to cause future spikes remains a background threat. Retailers must constantly monitor fuel markets and build resilience against potential shocks into their procurement strategies.
• Renewables reshaping the grid: The rapid growth of wind and solar power, particularly evident in Texas with its significant wind capacity and fast-growing solar generation, is fundamentally altering pricing dynamics. Abundant renewable output during sunny or windy periods pushes down wholesale prices, sometimes dramatically. Conversely, when renewable output drops (like solar power fading at dusk – the "duck curve"), the grid relies on other resources, potentially causing sharp price increases. This intra-day volatility requires new approaches. While real-time prices in ERCOT still hit the market cap ($5,000/MWh) during scarcity, these events have become less frequent, and average prices are significantly lower than in 2022. Nonetheless, the potential for volatility persists, driven by the interaction of weather, demand, and variable generation.

At the same time, there is uncertainty about the future for renewable energy due to recent political turbulence. We spoke at length about the possible impact that tariffs might have in this linked blog post. Since being published, the news has only confirmed fears, with a significant drop in funding and investment for renewable energy projects in the first quarter of 2025. 

“According to Mercom Capital Group, funding for solar companies saw a 41% decrease, while energy storage companies experienced an even steeper decline of 81% compared to the same period in the previous year” 

Policy crosswinds: navigating regulatory shifts

Layered on top of market volatility is a dynamic regulatory environment. Policymakers and regulators at federal, regional, and state levels are actively reshaping market rules, consumer protections, and the pathways to decarbonization.

• Market design evolution: Grid operators like ERCOT and PJM are refining their market mechanisms. ERCOT is notably accelerating the implementation of real-time co-optimization of energy and ancillary services, targeted for December 2025. This significant change aims to procure and dispatch resources more efficiently, potentially saving consumers over $1 billion annually in wholesale costs and enhancing reliability. PJM continues to adjust its capacity market parameters, following record high prices in the summer of 2024. Retailers must understand and adapt to these complex rule changes, which can alter risk profiles and procurement costs.
• Reliability and consumer protection focus: In the wake of events like Winter Storm Uri, regulators are intensely focused on grid reliability and consumer protection. The Texas PUC have implemented measures to incentivize reliability, such as adjustments to scarcity pricing mechanisms, and are exploring new frameworks like a Performance Credit Mechanism. In competitive PJM states like Illinois and Maryland, commissions have tightened rules around retail marketing practices to prevent misleading claims and protect consumers. While essential, these measures add compliance layers and can influence how retailers structure and market their offers.
• Enabling flexibility and new technologies: Policy is also paving the way for innovation. FERC Order 2222 requires grid operators to allow aggregated distributed energy resources (DERs) – like rooftop solar, batteries, and smart appliances – to participate in wholesale markets. This federal directive, alongside state initiatives like Texas's pilot programs for aggregating residential batteries as grid resources, creates significant opportunities for retailers to develop new products and services that leverage customer-sited assets. Furthermore, pushes towards advanced rate designs, like time-of-use pilots in Pennsylvania, signal a move towards pricing that better reflects real-time grid conditions.

Pricing amidst uncertainty

For energy retailers in deregulated US markets, this confluence of market volatility and policy shifts demands strategic adaptation. Margins remain tight due to intense competition and the need to offer compelling prices against utility default rates. Success hinges on moving beyond simply selling kilowatt-hours.

Innovative pricing and products: Standard flat rates are giving way to more creative offerings. Some Texas retailers leverage volatility with plans offering free electricity during specific periods (like nights or weekends) when wholesale prices are often low due to high renewable output. Integrating DERs opens doors for plans that reward customers for allowing their EV chargers, smart thermostats, or batteries to respond to grid needs. Retailers are also differentiating through 100% renewable energy plans and exploring value-added services beyond energy supply.

Offering tariffs specifically linked to renewable energy sources is another potential path. If the cost of renewables is less volatile or follows different patterns than fossil fuels, this can be an attractive option. However, even with the current disruption to renewable investment, there is likely to be a strong market for this kind of tariff, with many businesses committed to net-zero in their supply chain, while in the residential market there is undoubtedly a strong niche of green conscious consumers.

Thriving in uncertainty requires deep insights. Retailers are increasingly leveraging digital tools, AI, and automation. Advanced data platforms, like those offered by Gorilla, ingest vast datasets – market prices, weather forecasts, customer usage patterns, competitor actions – to optimize pricing, forecast demand and costs with greater accuracy, and manage risk in real-time. AI-driven pricing engines can dynamically adjust offers, while automation streamlines operations, reducing errors and cost-to-serve. This data-driven approach allows retailers to anticipate market shifts, tailor offers, and enhance forecasting accuracy, providing a crucial edge.

Other retailer strategies

Pricing is just one tool available to energy retailers when it comes to reacting to market changes; any successful strategy will require a holistic approach that takes into account the full range of options available. Some other potential moves include:

• Sophisticated risk management: Robust hedging is paramount. Retailers that navigated the recent volatility successfully often employed sophisticated trading operations and data analytics to manage their wholesale cost exposure. Post-Uri, many Texas customers shifted to fixed-rate plans for bill stability, requiring retailers to carefully manage the underlying commodity risk.
• Embracing demand flexibility: Perhaps the most significant strategic shift is the growing importance of demand flexibility. By incentivizing customers to shift energy use away from peak price periods – through time of use rates, real-time rebates, or direct load control programs – retailers can lower their overall procurement costs and reduce exposure to volatility spikes. Aggregating these flexible loads effectively creates a 'virtual power plant' that can act as a hedge and even participate in grid services markets, opening new revenue streams. Retailers are becoming orchestrators of customer energy use, not just suppliers.

The path forward: data-driven resilience

The energy pricing landscape through 2025 and beyond will likely feature continued moderation in average prices compared to the crisis peaks, but punctuated by volatility driven by weather and the accelerating energy transition. Regulatory frameworks will continue to evolve, aiming to balance the energy trilemma: affordability, reliability, and sustainability.

For energy retailers in competitive US markets, the key to navigating this future lies in embracing data-driven strategies and technological innovation. Uncertainty demands intelligence. By investing in advanced analytics, adopting flexible pricing models, empowering customers with tools and incentives, and actively engaging with the evolving policy landscape, retailers can transform challenges into competitive advantages.

At Gorilla, we believe data is the catalyst for resolving the energy trilemma. Our platform provides the tools and insights necessary to manage complexity, optimize pricing, and unlock the value of flexibility. In an era where the only constant is change, the ability to anticipate, adapt, and act based on robust data analysis isn't just beneficial – it's fundamental to building a resilient, profitable, and sustainable energy retail business prepared for the turbulence ahead.

‍